Disclosure: Masters of Gifts may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Prices and availability can change.
Short answer: No. A gift card is a good present when it's for a place or experience the person loves and you add a personal touch, like a handwritten note or a small treat. It only feels impersonal when it's generic, like a prepaid Visa card handed over with no message.
Gift cards have a reputation for being lazy, but plenty of people would rather have one than a gift they’ll return. The difference is thought: pick a place they love, add a note or a small gift, and it reads as personal. If you want something that still lets them choose, there are good alternatives too. For more help, see What to buy for Christmas.
How we chose: This is a researched shopping guide, not a hands-on product test. Every pick comes from products we researched for our full Masters of Gifts gift guides, and prices shown are the ones we last checked. Prices change, so check the retailer before you buy. Our editorial standards explain how we research every list.
Gift cards that feel personal
Cards tied to an experience or a hobby they love.
Topgolf gift card ($50)
Good at any Topgolf in the US. Heated hitting bays are one of the easiest ways to keep swinging when it's snowing outside.
Amazon price: $50.00 (checked October 27, 2026)
Universal Yums Yum Yum Box gift subscription
For the friend who's always curious about food. Each box brings 10 to 12 snacks from a different country, plus a booklet of trivia and games.
Universal Yums price: From $27 (checked October 18, 2026)
Pair a gift card with a small gift
A small treat makes a card feel finished.
Ghirardelli assorted chocolate squares, 12.5 oz bag
Individually wrapped Ghirardelli squares to drop a few into each bag.
Amazon price: $13.49 (checked October 27, 2026)
Burt's Bees Classics gift set
A Burt's Bees sampler with lip balm and hand cream.
Amazon price: $25.00 (checked October 27, 2026)
Alternatives that still let them choose
Gifts with built-in variety.
Amazon Kindle Paperwhite, 16GB
For the reader who wants a whole library in his backpack. The glare-free screen works in sunlight, and it's waterproof.
Amazon price: $199.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Atlas Coffee Club Gourmet Coffee Sampler, Ground, 4-Pack
Four 1.8-ounce bags from four countries, with postcards and tasting-note cards.
Amazon price: $39.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Skip this
A few gift card habits make them feel impersonal.
- Prepaid cards with fees. Some prepaid cards charge activation fees. A store card is better value.
- Gift cards for places they don't go. A card for a store across the country rarely gets used.
- No message. Always add a short note about why you picked it.
Gift card FAQ
Is it rude to give a gift card for Christmas?
No. Many people prefer gift cards. Pick a place they enjoy and add a personal note.
Are gift cards good for teenagers?
Yes. Teens often prefer to choose their own things, and gift cards for games, clothing or food are popular.
How do you make a gift card more personal?
Choose a place tied to their hobbies, add a handwritten note, and pair it with a small treat or something related.
