Disclosure: Masters of Gifts may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Prices and availability can change.
Short answer: When a 5-year-old has every toy, give her something to make or build instead: a paint-your-own moon lamp, a glow-in-the-dark rock painting kit, an art case or Magna-Tiles. If you want a big wow moment, an interactive pet like Little Live Pets is a reliable hit.
Kids who have every toy usually don’t have many projects. Craft kits, building sets and pretend-play gifts get used again and again, while one more doll often gets lost in the pile. Here are our favorite picks for a 5-year-old girl, sorted by type. For the full list, see our Best Christmas gifts for 5-year-old girls.
How we chose: This is a researched shopping guide, not a hands-on product test. Every pick comes from products we researched for our full Masters of Gifts gift guides, and prices shown are the ones we last checked. Prices change, so check the retailer before you buy. Our editorial standards explain how we research every list.
Creative projects she can make herself
Gifts she'll be proud to show off.
Paint Your Own Moon Lamp Kit
The Paint Your Own Moon Lamp Kit is a creative arts and crafts set that allows kids to design and personalize their own 3D moon night light.
Amazon price: $17.98 (checked October 27, 2026)
Glow-In-The-Dark Rock Painting Kit
A rock painting kit with glow-in-the-dark paints, so kids can decorate rocks for the garden or their room.
Amazon price: $14.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Crayola Inspiration Art Case, 140 pieces
For young artists. It has crayons, markers, colored pencils, and paper in a case that closes up for storage.
Amazon price: $26.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Building and pretend play
Open-ended toys that grow with her.
MAGNA-TILES Castle DLX 48-Piece Magnetic Construction Set
The Magna-Tiles Castle DLX 48-Piece Set is a creative building kit that lets kids construct their own magical castles.
Amazon price: $69.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Tiny Land Creative Forts Glowing Building Set
The Tiny Land Creative Fort Building Kit is an imaginative set that includes 130 pieces, allowing kids to construct their own forts, tunnels, and structures.
Amazon price: $42.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Play-Doh Pizza Delivery Scooter Playset
The Play-Doh Pizza Delivery Kids Scooter Playset offers a creative and fun experience for young chefs and delivery enthusiasts.
Amazon price: $78.50 (checked October 27, 2026)
Big wow gifts
For the gift she opens last.
Little Live Pets My Really Real Puppy
The Little Live Pets My Really Real Puppy, Patches, offers kids an interactive pet experience without the responsibilities of a real puppy.
Amazon price: $50.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Hello Kitty & Friends Claw Machine
The Hello Kitty and Friends Claw Machine is a delightful miniature arcade experience for fans of all ages.
Amazon price: $49.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Photo Creator Instant Print Camera by Canal Toys
The Canal Toys Photo Creator Instant Camera is a fun and creative way for kids to capture and print their own photos instantly.
Amazon price: $49.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Skip this
A few gifts usually disappoint at this age.
- Toys with tiny pieces for a younger sibling's house. Check for little siblings before buying sets with small parts.
- Duplicates of popular characters. Ask parents which characters she already has.
- Messy kits without a heads-up. Slime and paint kits are fun, but give parents a warning.
Gifts for a 5-year-old girl FAQ
What do 5-year-old girls want for Christmas?
Interactive pets, building sets like Magna-Tiles, craft kits and pretend-play sets are all popular.
What is a good non-toy gift for a 5-year-old?
Craft kits, art supplies, books and experiences like a class or outing are great non-toy gifts.
How much should you spend on a gift for a 5-year-old?
Most relatives spend $20 to $50. Craft kits and books fit easily in that range.
