Disclosure: Masters of Gifts may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Prices and availability can change.
Short answer: A great Christmas gift basket mixes something sweet, something savory and something to drink, packed in a reusable base like a charcuterie board. Try chocolates, butter cookies, hot sauce, jerky, gourmet tea and a coffee sampler.
The best gift baskets feel balanced: a few sweets, a couple of savory snacks, something to sip and a container worth keeping. Choose a theme, like movie night, coffee break or charcuterie, and build around it. Here are the items we’d use, sorted by type. For ready-made options, see our 55 best Christmas food gifts.
How we chose: This is a researched shopping guide, not a hands-on product test. Every pick comes from products we researched for our full Masters of Gifts gift guides, and prices shown are the ones we last checked. Prices change, so check the retailer before you buy. Our editorial standards explain how we research every list.
A base and something sweet
Start with a container and a crowd-pleaser.
SMIRLY charcuterie board set with serving accessories
A practical hosting gift when they want the board, serving pieces, and presentation handled in one set.
Amazon price: $69.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Ghirardelli assorted chocolate squares, 12.5 oz bag
Individually wrapped Ghirardelli squares to drop a few into each bag.
Amazon price: $13.49 (checked October 27, 2026)
Royal Dansk butter cookies tin, 24 oz
The classic blue tin of Danish butter cookies, a tin people reuse for years.
Amazon price: $14.98 (checked October 27, 2026)
Savory snacks
Something salty to balance the sweets.
TRUFF black truffle and habanero hot sauce 2-pack
The fancy hot sauce that shows up on a lot of gift lists, and for good reason. It's great on eggs and pizza.
Amazon price: $29.98 (checked October 27, 2026)
Jack Link's beef jerky variety pack
Original and teriyaki jerky packs he can stash in the truck, office drawer, or tackle box.
Amazon price: $18.39 (checked October 27, 2026)
Tabañero variety hot sauce 4-pack
Four bottles of hot sauce for under $10. It's a cheap stocking stuffer that still feels like a real gift.
Amazon price: $9.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Something to sip
Tea and coffee round out the basket.
Twinings tea bag sampler, 44 count
A 44-bag Twinings sampler to split into tea bundles for the tea drinkers.
Amazon price: $14.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Sampler Coffee Variety Pack
Six small bags of specialty coffee to try one at a time.
Amazon price: $23.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Starbucks Holiday Blend K-Cup pods
Seasonal coffee pods for the office Keurig regular.
Amazon price: $16.94 (checked October 27, 2026)
Skip this
A few gift basket mistakes to avoid.
- Filler. Shredded paper and cheap candy make a basket look full but feel thin.
- Items that melt or spoil. Chocolate can melt in transit, and fresh foods spoil. Pick shelf-stable items.
- Ignoring allergies. Check for nut, gluten or dairy allergies before you shop.
Gift basket FAQ
What do you put in a homemade Christmas gift basket?
Mix chocolates or cookies, a savory snack like jerky or hot sauce, and tea or coffee, all in a reusable base.
How much should you put in a Christmas gift basket?
Most homemade baskets have five to eight items and cost $40 to $80.
What can I use instead of a basket?
A charcuterie board, a mixing bowl, a crate or a tote bag all make great reusable bases.
