Disclosure: Masters of Gifts may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Prices and availability can change.
Short answer: For a new boyfriend, keep it thoughtful but light, usually $25 to $75. A useful upgrade like a Bluetooth speaker or a quality beanie, a grooming treat like Dr. Squatch soap, or a gift for a date, like a Topgolf gift card, all hit the right note without being too serious.
Your first Christmas together comes with a quiet question: how much is too much? The safe answer is something he’ll use, something that shows you pay attention, or something you can do together, without a big price tag or anything too sentimental. For more ideas, see our 60 great gifts for men who have everything.
How we chose: This is a researched shopping guide, not a hands-on product test. Every pick comes from products we researched for our full Masters of Gifts gift guides, and prices shown are the ones we last checked. Prices change, so check the retailer before you buy. Our editorial standards explain how we research every list.
Thoughtful but not too serious
Gifts that show you pay attention.
Carhartt Iconic A18 watch cap beanie
The Carhartt beanie, with more than 175,000 ratings. It fits almost everyone and comes in dozens of colors.
Amazon price: $19.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
Dr. Squatch men's bar soap, 3-pack
Three natural men's bar soaps with more than 87,000 ratings. He'll notice the upgrade from drugstore soap.
Amazon price: $22.94 (checked October 27, 2026)
Jason Markk shoe cleaning kit
A cleaning solution and brush that make dirty sneakers look new again. It's a must for the guy who cares about his shoes.
Amazon price: $18.00 (checked October 27, 2026)
Things he'll use every day
Practical gifts that still feel like gifts.
Anker 10,000mAh portable power bank
A slim battery pack that charges a phone about twice. It's the kind of thing he'll keep in a bag for years.
Amazon price: $20.89 (checked October 27, 2026)
Soundcore by Anker P20i wireless earbuds
Budget earbuds with more than 117,000 ratings. They're a good spare pair for the gym or the car.
Amazon price: $22.99 (checked October 27, 2026)
JBL Go 4 portable Bluetooth speaker
A small, waterproof JBL speaker.
Amazon price: $49.95 (checked October 27, 2026)
Something to do together
A gift that turns into a date.
Mixology & Craft whiskey glasses and chilling stones set
Two crystal whiskey glasses, eight granite chilling stones, and two slate coasters in one box. It's rated 4.8 stars.
Amazon price: $24.69 (checked October 27, 2026)
Codenames board game, 2nd edition
A team word-guessing game for game nights.
Amazon price: $24.97 (checked October 27, 2026)
Topgolf gift card ($50)
Good at any Topgolf in the US. Heated hitting bays are one of the easiest ways to keep swinging when it's snowing outside.
Amazon price: $50.00 (checked October 27, 2026)
Skip this
A few gifts are a lot for a new relationship.
- Jewelry or anything engraved. It can feel too serious too soon.
- Very expensive tech. A big price tag can make things awkward if his gift to you is smaller.
- Clothing in a guessed size. Accessories like a beanie are safer.
New boyfriend gift FAQ
How much should you spend on a new boyfriend for Christmas?
Most people spend $25 to $75 in the first few months. Talking about a budget ahead of time is fine, too.
What is a good first Christmas gift for a boyfriend?
A useful gift like a speaker or power bank, a grooming treat, or an experience you can share, like Topgolf.
Should a first Christmas gift be romantic?
Light and thoughtful usually works better than very romantic early on. Save sentimental gifts for later.
